Close Menu
    • Top Fintech Startups in Switzerland
    • Switzerland Fintech Startup List
    • Virtual Banking
    • Open Banking
    • Online Mortgage
    • Regtech
    • Fintech Events
    • Submit Press Release
    • Submit Startup
    Facebook LinkedIn X (Twitter) Instagram RSS
    • About Fintech News Network
    • Media Kit
    • Contact Us
    • Work With Us
    • Newsletter
    • Submit Press Release
    • Submit Startup
    • Impressum
    Fintech Schweiz Digital Finance News – FintechNewsCH
    part of Fintech News Network

    Fintech News Network

    Facebook LinkedIn X (Twitter) Instagram RSS
    Free Newsletter
    • Blockchain
    • Wealthtech
    • Lending
    • Mobile Payments
    • Insurtech
    • PFM
    • AI
    • Funding
    • Various
      1. Germany
      2. London
      3. USA
      4. Austria
      5. Liechtenstein
      6. View All

      BaFin Fines Deutsche Bank €8 Million Over Postbank Migration Issues

      November 13, 2026

      Affirm Acquires Ratepay as Nexi Focuses on Core Activities

      November 10, 2026

      Eurex Clearing to Handle Digital and Traditional Assets Together

      November 4, 2026

      Deutsche Börse Extends Access to DAX 40 Stocks Beyond Xetra Hours

      October 28, 2026

      Griffin Raises US$20M to Add Card and Stablecoin Services

      November 13, 2026

      HSBC UK Launches Stripe-Powered Tap to Pay for Small Businesses

      November 12, 2026

      UBS Job Cuts Hit London as Credit Suisse Integration Enters Final Phase

      November 6, 2026

      Monzo Weighs New Funding at £7.5 Billion Valuation as Buyout Talks Stall

      November 6, 2026

      Wise Expands into US Investing via Its Broker-Dealer Licence

      November 16, 2026

      Anchorage Digital and Visa Add USDPT as a Settlement Option

      November 13, 2026

      Swiss Wealthtech Firm Avaloq Expands Into US Market

      November 11, 2026

      Morgan Stanley Eyes Tokenisation With Vinyl Equity Deal

      November 10, 2026

      Revolut Austria Banking Branch to Launch in 2027 With Local IBANs

      November 5, 2026

      BingX EU Secures MiCA Licence for Crypto Services in Europe

      October 15, 2026

      Bitget Pauses Withdrawals Following US$351.6M Hot Wallet Hack

      September 25, 2026

      Bybit Payments Secures Austria EMI License for European Payment Services

      August 5, 2026

      Swiss and Liechtenstein Banks Resist Core Banking System Overhaul

      November 11, 2026

      Swiss Blockchain Survey 2026: Banks on Stablecoins and Tokenized Funds

      October 20, 2026

      Bank Frick Enables Real-Time Euro Transfers and CHF Payment Receipts

      July 21, 2026

      Celsion Bank Begins Operations, Combining Digital Assets and Traditional Banking

      April 10, 2026

      Top Finfluencers in Switzerland in 2026

      November 10, 2026

      88% of Tech Founders Walk Away with Zero Exit Value

      November 9, 2026

      MUFG Bank Europe Absorbs Securities Arm to Become EU Universal Bank

      November 4, 2026

      Swiss Officials Weigh the Costs of a UBS Relocation Abroad

      October 30, 2026
    • More
      • Fintech Events
      • Top Swiss Fintechs in 2026
      • Swiss Fintech Startup List
      • Accelerators
    Fintech Schweiz Digital Finance News – FintechNewsCH

    Fintech News Network

    Home»Various»IMF Study: Fintech Poses a Threat to Traditional Financial Institutions
    Various

    IMF Study: Fintech Poses a Threat to Traditional Financial Institutions

    Fintechnews SwitzerlandFintechnews SwitzerlandJanuary 5, 20246 Mins Read
    LinkedIn Facebook Twitter Telegram Copy Link Email
    Fintech Poses a Threat to Traditional Financial Institutions, New Study Finds
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Telegram Copy Link Email
    Free Newsletter

    Get the hottest Fintech Switzerland News once a month in your Inbox

    The rise of fintech is posing a threat to traditional financial institutions, with these emerging companies encroaching on incumbents’ market share. This is evidenced by the adverse impact of fintech on the profitability of established financial institutions, a new research by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) found.

    The findings, shared in a paper titled “Is Fintech Eating the Bank’s Lunch?”, were drawn from an analysis of a cross-country database encompassing 10,167 financial institutions and data on digital finance activities across 57 countries. The study sought to gain insights into the relationship between fintech and financial institutions’ profitability and examine the impact of the rise of fintech on banking sector.

    Findings of the study reveal that established financial institutions are witnessing a negative impact on their profitability when the presence of fintech companies is high, an impact that’s primarily driven by reduced interest income due to heightened competition in the lending market as well as increased costs.

    Bottomline

    Specially, the study found that a 1% point increase in fintech transaction volumes correlates with a reduction of 0.09% points in return on equity (ROE) and a 0.02% points decline in return on assets (ROA) for incumbent financial institutions. An analysis of the transmission channels also uncovered a negative impact on net interest margin (NIM), with a 1% point increase in fintech transaction volumes prompting a 0.03% point decrease in incumbent’s NIM.

    Effect of fintech on bank performance measures, Source: Is Fintech Eating the Bank’s Lunch?, International Monetary Fund, Nov 2023
    Effect of fintech on bank performance measures, Source: Is Fintech Eating the Bank’s Lunch?, International Monetary Fund, Nov 2023

    Furthermore, fintech appears to have an adverse effect on incumbent’s cost to income (CTI), with a 1% point increase in fintech transaction volumes leading to a 0.14% point increase in incumbent CTI. According to the IMF, this could be attributed to the higher level of IT investments required because of fintech pressure. These costs are exacerbated by outdated legacy technology, further impacting profitability.

    In parallel, the analysis found that fintech has a positive effect on non-interest income (NONIC), with a 1% point increase in fintech transaction volumes being associated with a 0.01% point increase in incumbent NONIC. This result suggests that, although incumbents are responding to the intense competition by exploring new revenue streams, these efforts to diversify have not fully offset the profitability losses from fintech competition.

    Impact of different fintech business models

    Delving deeper into the fintech sector, the study found that different fintech models have varying effects on financial institutions with cooperative banks tending to experience greater profit deterioration from P2P lending and balance sheet lending than larger, more complex commercial banks.

    Results show that for a 1% point increase in P2P lending transactions, cooperative banks are witnessing a 0.3% point decrease in ROE. Likewise, a similar increase in balance sheet lending results in a 0.2% point ROE decrease. These results are significant given that the median ROE for cooperative banks is 3.8%, the report notes.

    Low profit levels for cooperative banks are attributed to reduced NIM and higher CTI. Some of these institutions are facing challenges in affording IT investments and meeting digital banking expectations, potentially limiting lending opportunities, the report notes. Fintech platforms, on the other hand, can achieve economies of scale and broader geographical reach by leveraging technology. Moreover, these platforms may target the same untapped customer segments that cooperative banks aim to serve.

    In contrast to cooperative banks, commercial banks seem to be less affected by fintech, potentially due to their larger size and wider geographical reach. In fact, the study found a positive effect of the presence of P2P lending on the NONIC of commercial banks, indicating potential benefits from collaboration with P2P lending platforms to expand revenue streams. However, balance sheet lending was found to be a threat to commercial bank, impacting their NIM negatively.

    Effect of fintech models on bank performance measures, Source: Is Fintech Eating the Bank’s Lunch?, International Monetary Fund, Nov 2023
    Effect of fintech models on bank performance measures, Source: Is Fintech Eating the Bank’s Lunch?, International Monetary Fund, Nov 2023

    Disparities between markets

    Looking at geographical trends and disparities, the study found that incumbents located in markets with lower bank concentration, higher stock market turnover, higher credit depth, and higher commercial bank profitability are more prone to losing ground to fintech companies.

    Lower bank concentration suggests fewer entry barriers for new fintech firms, and higher stock market turnover and credit depth imply more competitive and developed financial systems, indicating more sophisticated investors, and access to skilled talent. These conditions are advantageous for fintech success but pose a threat to incumbent profits, the report says.

    At the institutional level, incumbents with a lower risk profile, including lower non-performing loans (NPLs), a lower probability of insolvency, and higher capital, are more susceptible to see their profitability decline because of fintech. This is because financial institutions with these characteristics are more risk-averse and less inclined to lend, introducing opportunities for fintech firms to fill the gaps by serving as substitutes for traditional bank lending.

    Finally, the study found that in countries with high regulatory quality and government effectiveness, incumbent profitability tends to be positively impacted by fintech competition. This suggests that well-designed regulations can establish a level playing field, enabling new fintech companies to thrive while protecting incumbents from unfair competition practices.

    Study Recommendations

    The report concludes by emphasizing the importance of ongoing monitoring of fintech development and its impact across the financial system, noting that while fintech platforms are delivering benefits such as enhanced efficiency in financial service delivery, increased competition, and improved access to finance, the sector also presents challenges to incumbent institutions by limiting their profit margins and eroding their market shares.

    Consequently, banks may encounter difficulties in building capital buffers necessary for absorbing losses and maintaining solvency. There is also the potential for incumbents to engage in riskier lending and investment activities to preserve market share and boost profits.

    These risks and challenges require regulators to establish a proper framework that balances financial innovation and systemic risk mitigation. The report proposes a number of recommendations to broaden the regulatory scope and establish a level playing field, advocating for the review and redesign of licensing regimes to encompass new service providers within the regulatory framework where appropriate, the implementation of more robust capital, liquidity, and operational risk management requirements tailored to the risks posed by different fintech business models, and the enhancement of the regulatory framework for smaller, less technologically advanced incumbents that are more vulnerable to fintech competition.

    The IMF also encourages incumbents to respond to the rise of fintech and their growing threat by adjusting their business models, focusing on enhancing cost efficiency, diversifying income sources, consolidating operations, improving internal governance, and addressing problematic loans.

     

    Featured image credit: edited from freepik

    Sponsored ReportThe Payments Intelligence GapRead
    Remove term: traditional banking sector traditional banking sector
    Share. Facebook LinkedIn Twitter Telegram Copy Link Email

    Author

    fintech switzerland
    Fintechnews Switzerland
    • Facebook
    • X (Twitter)

    Related Posts

    Top Finfluencers in Switzerland in 2026

    November 10, 2026

    88% of Tech Founders Walk Away with Zero Exit Value

    November 9, 2026

    MUFG Bank Europe Absorbs Securities Arm to Become EU Universal Bank

    November 4, 2026

    Swiss Officials Weigh the Costs of a UBS Relocation Abroad

    October 30, 2026

    Lagarde to Step Down as ECB President on 7 February 2027

    October 30, 2026

    Top 9 Emerging Fintech Providers from Europe

    October 28, 2026

    Swiss UBS Job Cuts Could Grow by Up to 12,000, Bank Union Warns

    October 26, 2026

    EU Financial Institutions Employ Deceptive UX Design, Addictive App Features

    October 21, 2026
    AI Sponsored

    81% of Financial Firms Use AI. Only 14% Call It Transformational

    October 21, 2026
    Fintech Newsletter
    Subscribe to the most important Fintech Switzerland News
    Follow Us
    • Facebook
    • X / Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Instagram
    Swiss Fintech Startup Directory

    Swiss Fintech Startup Directory

    Top Swiss Fintech Startups

    Top Fintech Startups in Switzerland for 2026

    Upcoming Fintech Events
    Country
    AI & Big Data Expo Global 2027
    February 3, 2027
    -
    February 4, 2027
    United Kingdom
    -
    London
    Digital Finance Summit 2026
    December 3, 2026
    Belgium
    -
    Brussels
    Digital Society 2026
    November 25, 2026
    Germany
    -
    Frankfurt am Main
    EURO FINANCE Tech Day 2026
    November 18, 2026
    Germany
    -
    Frankfurt
    European Digital Finance Conference 2026
    November 19, 2026
    Netherlands
    -
    Amsterdam
    Promote Event View More
    Whitepapers & E-Books
    The Future of Competitive Advantage in Banking & Payments
    The Future of Competitive Advantage in Banking & Payments
    Bottomline
    American Newsletter

    Fintech News America

    Australia Fintech Map

    Australia Fintech Map

    Philippines Fintech Report

    SINGAPORE FINTECH REPORT

    Singapore Fintech Map 2025

    Indonesia Fintech Report

    Indonesia Fintech Map 2025 banner

    UAE Fintech Report

    UAE Fintech Report 2024

    Free Business Accounts

    Navigation
    • About Fintech News Network
    • FNN Media Kit
    • Work With Us
    • Contact Us
    • Fintech Switzerland Newsletter
    • Submit Press Release
    • Submit Fintech Startup
    • Datenschutzerklärung / Impressum
    Other Fintech News Network Publications
    Fintech News Switzerland
    Fintech News Singapore
    Fintech News Malaysia
    Fintech News Hong Kong
    Fintech News Philippines
    Fintech News Network Indonesia
    Fintech News Network Australia
    Fintech News Baltic
    Fintech News Nordics
    Fintech News America
    Fintech News UAE
    Fintech News Africa
    Get Informed

    Subscribe to Updates

    Subscribe to the most important Fintech Switzerland News

    Facebook LinkedIn X (Twitter) Instagram RSS
    • About Fintech News Network
    • FNN Media Kit
    • Work With Us
    • Contact Us
    • Fintech Switzerland Newsletter
    • Submit Press Release
    • Submit Fintech Startup
    • Datenschutzerklärung / Impressum
    © 2015 - 2026 Copyright CK Finanzpro GmbH. All Rights reserved.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Fintech Schweiz Digital Finance News - FintechNewsCH
    Manage Consent

    Your Privacy Matters to Us

    To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.

    Functional Always active
    The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
    Preferences
    The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
    Statistics
    The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
    Marketing
    The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
    • Manage options
    • Manage services
    • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
    • Read more about these purposes
    View preferences
    • {title}
    • {title}
    • {title}